Key Takeaways
|
Individuals with diabetes can consume bananas. By considering the overall portion size and the other items in the meal, bananas can fit into a balanced dietary pattern. There is no need to eliminate this fruit simply due to its natural sweetness.
The main factors to consider will be how much you are eating, how ripe it is and how it is cooked. A small, firm banana as a snack will not affect your sugar the same way as 2 very ripe bananas in a milkshake.
Can a Diabetic Eat Banana Daily? How Many Bananas a Day?
Many people can. A banana is a whole fruit and contains fibre, potassium and vitamin B6. It does not need to be avoided.
The main consideration with banana is the amount of carbohydrate it contains. All bananas contain some carbohydrate and your blood sugar will mainly depend on how much you are eating in one go. A large banana will contain more than a small one. If you are having it with a plate of poha, this will increase the amount of carbohydrate you are having. As a general guide, one small banana or half a large banana at a time (around 1 fruit exchange) is a sensible starting point. How many bananas you can have in a day depends on your overall carbohydrate plan and how your readings respond, so check this with your care team.
Banana Glycemic Index: How Does Ripeness Affect Blood Sugar?
A banana will change as it ripens. When it is green it will be firm and not very sweet. After a few days it will turn yellow and be softer. If left for longer it will develop brown patches on the skin and become very soft and sweet.
This is due to the change in carbohydrate content. A green banana will contain mostly starch. Much of this will be resistant starch. Resistant starch is a type of starch that is not easily digested by the body and acts like fibre. As the banana ripens, the starch will slowly convert to sugars and be absorbed quicker. The glycemic index (GI) shows how quickly a food raises blood sugar compared with glucose. A GI of 55 or less is considered low, and 70 or more is considered high.
| A small study of 10 people with type 2 diabetes showed that under ripe bananas caused less of a rise in blood sugar than over ripe bananas. Under ripe bananas had a GI of around 43 compared to over ripe bananas with a GI of around 74 (Hermansen et al., 1992). Another small study of 7 men with type 2 diabetes found very little differences in blood sugar responses between the 4 stages of ripeness (Ercan et al., 1993). |
These studies are small and were carried out decades ago. They also used set amounts of banana for testing. Overall ripeness may make some difference but it is not the whole story. A very ripe banana does not have to be avoided. You may just want to eat a smaller portion.
Wondering how banana fits into your diabetes diet?
Is Raw Banana Good for Diabetes?
Raw banana (kachcha kela) can be a useful vegetable to include in a diabetes diet. However, it will not be exactly the same as eating a green dessert banana.
Most raw bananas used in Indian cooking will be a cooking variety. They will almost always be cooked. This means the starch will soften and be easier to digest. A bowl of raw banana sabzi will not contain the same amount of resistant starch as an uncooked green banana.
How it is cooked:
- Boiled or steamed – raw banana will be simple. No extra fat will be added.
- Sabzi with a little oil – a common and reasonable option, especially if you are having it with dal or curd.
- Fried (chips or bhajji) – will add lots of oil. It can be easy to overeat.
Raw banana is still a starchy food so should be counted as part of the carbohydrate in your meal, like potato.
| Study Highlight A 24 week trial was carried out with 113 adults with prediabetes or type 2 diabetes. They were divided into two groups. One group received dietary advice and 40g of green banana biomass daily. The other group received only dietary advice. Both groups saw improvements in HbA1c. The green banana group also saw improvements in fasting glucose and body weight (Costa et al., 2019). |
However, the exploratory analysis did not find a statistically significant difference in HbA1c or fasting glucose improvement between the two groups. This study used specially prepared green banana biomass. This cannot be directly related to eating raw banana sabzi at home.
Choosing Banana for Diabetes: Ripeness, Portion and Preparation
Consider the following:
- Ripeness – Is it firm, yellow or very ripe? A firm banana may cause a slightly slower rise in your sugars.
- Quantity – How much are you having? Half a large banana will be around 1 fruit exchange (15g of carbohydrate). A full large banana will be around 2. Banana can vary in size so this is just a general guide. This information was taken from an Indian fruit exchange list from Novo Nordisk India.
- How it is cooked – Whole, cooked, fried or in a shake? A banana milkshake will add the carbohydrate from the milk and often sugar. It can be easy to drink a lot quickly.
| Banana type | What’s happening inside | What it means for you |
| Green dessert banana | Contains more starch, including resistant starch, than a ripe banana | May raise sugar more slowly, but it’s firm and not everyone enjoys it |
| Yellow banana | Starch turning into sugar | A good everyday choice in a measured portion |
| Very ripe banana with brown spots | More of its starch has converted into sugars | Fine occasionally, but you may want a smaller portion |
| Boiled raw banana | Cooked starch, easier to digest | Count it as a starchy vegetable, like potato |
| Fried raw banana | Starch plus a lot of added oil | Best kept for occasional use |
“The same banana may affect 2 people differently. Your medication, activity throughout the day, sleep and what you are having with it will all affect how your blood sugar reacts. If you are monitoring your glucose at home, you can monitor how you are reacting to a meal containing banana. Follow the timings and targets your care team advise.”
Dr. Bipin Gond, Zonal Medical Head, Madhavbaug
How to Eat Banana With Indian Meals
Banana will usually be eaten with other foods:
- Poha/upma – Poha is mainly a carbohydrate so a large banana on the side will add up quickly. Have half a banana or keep the banana and have a smaller portion of poha.
- Roti – If you are having banana as part of a meal with roti or rice, think of it as part of your carbohydrate.
- Dahi – Plain unsweetened dahi with a few slices of banana makes a filling snack. The protein in the dahi will make it more satisfying.
- Nuts – A handful of almonds or peanuts with half a banana makes a great mid morning or evening snack. Nuts will add protein and healthy fats but will not offset the carbohydrate.
| General Tip Try to spread your carbohydrate throughout the day. Plan what you are having with your banana. |
When Should I Seek Individual Advice?
General advice can be followed by many people. However, the following may need more consideration:
- If you are on insulin or a sulfonylurea (type of diabetes tablet that can cause low blood sugars), changing the amount of fruit or carbohydrate you are having can affect your readings. Speak to your doctor.
- If you have kidney disease you may have been told to be careful with your potassium. Banana is a high potassium fruit. Ask your doctor if it is suitable for you and how much you can have.
- If you are on a structured diet at Madhavbaug (such as the Prameha Diet Kit) you may have more restrictions on fruit. Follow the guidelines.
| Clinical Insight “Sometimes a high reading after eating banana may not be due to just the banana. How much you are having, what you are having with it, how active you have been and what medication you are currently on for your diabetes can all affect this. Looking at your glucose patterns, HbA1c and what you are eating can help a clinician decide if you need to make changes to your banana portion, meal or other part of your management plan.” Dr. Pravin Jayram Ghadigaonkar, BAMS, MD, PhD (Scholar) – Preventive Cardiology 20+ Years of Clinical Experience, Head Medical Operations & Patient Improvement, Madhavbaug |
Managing Diabetes at Madhavbaug
At Madhavbaug, diabetes care starts with a look at your medical history, reports and daily routine. We may then offer you individualised dietary advice, lifestyle changes, regular follow ups and doctor supervised Ayurvedic treatment. This will be alongside your prescribed medications, not instead of them.
Want a diet plan that fits your reports and routine?
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a diabetic eat a whole banana?
Many people can. A whole large banana will be around 2 fruit exchanges. It may be easier to start with half a banana or a small banana. Monitor your readings to see how it works for you.
Is a very ripe banana bad for diabetes?
Not necessarily. However, it will contain more sugar and less starch. This may cause a slightly quicker rise in your sugars. A simple way to include it would be to have a smaller portion.
Is raw banana better for diabetes?
Raw banana is usually cooked. This will make the starch easier to digest. It can be a good vegetable to include. However, it is a starchy food so should be treated like potato. Try not to fry it too often.
What is the best time to eat banana if you have diabetes?
There is no set time. Many people find it easier to have it as a planned snack. Monitor your readings to see what works best for you.
Can I eat banana with poha?
Yes! However, both are mainly carbohydrate. Try having half a banana or a smaller portion of poha.
Does banana cause a quick rise in blood sugar?
It can. If it is very ripe or a large portion. A smaller portion of a less ripe banana may cause a different response. Eating it with plain dahi or nuts can also change how your meal is digested. However, it will not offset the carbohydrate and does not guarantee a smaller rise.
References
Costa, E.S. et al. (2019) ‘Beneficial effects of green banana biomass consumption in patients with pre-diabetes and type 2 diabetes: a randomised controlled trial’, British Journal of Nutrition, 121(12), pp. 1365–1375.
Ercan, N., Nuttall, F.Q., Gannon, M.C., Lane, J.T., Burmeister, L.A. and Westphal, S.A. (1993) ‘Plasma glucose and insulin responses to bananas of varying ripeness in persons with noninsulin-dependent diabetes mellitus’, Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 12(6), pp. 703–709.
Hermansen, K., Rasmussen, O., Gregersen, S. and Larsen, S. (1992) ‘Influence of ripeness of banana on the blood glucose and insulin response in type 2 diabetic subjects’, Diabetic Medicine, 9(8), pp. 739–743.
Novo Nordisk India (n.d.) Fruit exchange list. Available at:








